Let’s see if I’m totally out of line with this opinion, or if some of you can relate… I like the idea of Nutella, but in practice it’s just too over-the-top unhealthy most of the time. The stuff is overwhelmingly sweet, slick with excess oil, and frankly… not real food. I’m not above a little candy here and there, but the problem is that a nutty chocolate spread doesn’t need to be such a dietary disaster.
I had been wanting to experiment with a superior spread for a while, but I don’t have a food processor and I was wary of grinding up nuts in my blender. Luckily, Jeanine from Love and Lemons is smarter than me and recently shared a spread that circumvents this issue entirely by starting the recipe with almond butter. Duh!! I’m so thankful for the internet.
As a bonus, this is the kind of recipe I can even pass along to friends who aren’t into cooking. It’s extremely simple: Almond butter. Dark chocolate. Coconut oil. I took creative liberty and added an extra tablespoon of high-quality cocoa powder to really push the flavor, and you guys… it’s so much better than Nutella.
This spread is bittersweet perfection, just the way I like it. If I’m eating chocolate, I want it to taste like CHOCOLATE. And due to our wholesome ingredients, each tablespoon has only 2 grams of sugar, while Nutella has over 10!
It’s good enough to stand on its own, but I prefer to enjoy it by loading it up with fruit.

You can see a little grainy texture from the almond butter… but I like it that way! It’s made of real food, and proud of it! #hippienutella
So… what’s the next thing I should spread my spread on? Don’t even act like you don’t have ideas, because I know you do.
This looks REALLY good. I think almond and chocolate go together at least as well as hazelnut and chocolate. I will say though, have you tried Justin’s “chocolate hazelnut spread” (from Justin’s nut butters)? It is like Nutella but way less sweet and oily. You might like it, I definitely do.
Oooh… thanks for the heads up, I’ll check it out!
hey there! this seems soo delicious i cant wait to try it! i was wondering if i could just omit the chocolate and just use cocoa powder do you think would that work?
thanks xx
Hey thanks! You know, I think I’m going to try that out on my next batch. It might make the consistency a little less creamy, an extra tablespoon of coconut oil would probably help if that happens. It’s pretty foolproof!